Plato's Cave:
The Tribune's editorial blog

Monday, January 01, 2007

More Dream Headlines
The Salt Lake Tribune's New Year's Day Our View was given over to the fifth annual collection of Dream Headlines. Those are readers' submissions of headlines they hope to see in the coming year. As always, the subjects ranged from the serious to the absurd, on topics global to local. And, as always, we received far more than we had room for in the newspaper.

But, then, that's what the Internet is for.

Here are many more of the submissions we were pleased to receive. Some of them are here, not in print, simply because they are technically too long to be headlines. Some of them may be a bit obscure. Think yourself bright and incisive if you get it. Think the author obtuse and thick if you don't.

Thanks to all who played along. And Happy New Year!

-- George Pyle

Kirby becomes serious and makes sense

Trib eliminates annoying sticky note on newspaper

NFL team comes to Salt Lake

TRAX gets understandable speakers on trains

No one died in Iraq today

-- Ed Hall

DeLay, Abramoff, Rumsfeld awarded Medal of Freedom

Supreme Court: Constitution declared unconstitutional

Iraq situation upgraded to monumental tragedy

-- Paul Zelenka

Rocky Anderson seeks Mexican presidency

-- Harry W. Patrick

Bush, Cheney resign; Pelosi takes oath

Hatch composes ballet: The Nutcaker

-- Frank Musgrave

Mary Brown Malouf finally finds restaurant she can stomach

Larry H. Miller bails-out Real Salt Lake

-- Paul McGill

Larry H. Miller caves; Arena renamed US Airways Center

U.S. signs Kyoto

TSA stays stupid airport security rules

-- Scott Widmer

Democracy restored in USA: World watches

No more torture! Geneva not "quaint"

Utah public ed leads nation

-- Dennis L. Kay

Cannon out; Bagley to edit D-News

Conway out; Kirby to edit Tribune

-- Fred Brady

Bush impeached

Monkey Wrench Gang finally succeeds

Washington Co. land boom busts

-- Edwin Firmage Jr.

Scientists find red meat & lard have health benefits

-- Arthur Reilly

Questar provides free green stickers

-- Joyce Scott

Independent investigation launched for 9/11 crimes

-- Curtis Holt

Hinckley decries Utah theocracy; says 'Get real"

-- W. Ellington

Harvard and Yale abolish legacy admissions based on Bush presidential performance

U.S. troops push south to Panama in search of defendable southern border

-- Lew Baker

Nothing left to chance: Utah Lottery funds education

-- Brigitte Klement

Huntsman education plan: 'Adopt-a-Teacher'

Polygamists provide critical swing vote for Romney

-- Mike Ptaschinski

Hinckley reveals: Shun promiscuity, promote gay marriage

Mullen recants, returns to Tribune

-- Peggy Fujimura

Tribune hires a conservative to replace Mullen

-- James R. Clendenon

Bush administration on trial for war crimes

-- D. Wood

U.S. no longer largest arms dealer

Cheap, clean fusion power for all

-- Will Crowther

Hatch resigns: 'We lost our way, I'm sorry'

People take back government from business

Bush has epiphany: People mean more than money and power

-- Mike Coronella

Legislature repeals everything, adjourns, order ensues

-- Rob Latham

Monorail will connect City Creek Center to Gateway

Lake Powell filled to capacity

-- J.L. Smith

Mitt Romney changes mind again, wants Hillary as running mate

-- Alan E. Wright

Scores emulate Huntsmans: Thousand foster kids adopted

-- James Schnitter

Utah leads nation in science education

Teaching evolution becomes mandatory in Utah schools

-- Steven Peck

Mullen returns; editor fired

-- Willard G. Smith

Bush, Cheney impeached

-- Glen V. Ruff

Iraqi government orders all coalition forces out of country immediately

-- Joe Cronin

Utah's new 4th District elects Democrat

al-Sadr: Democracy is better than Sharia

Gov confesses: I'm really a Democrat

-- Ann Kamp

Huntsman Cancer Center finds cure for breast cancer

Brian David Mitchell behaves in court

Original Book of Mormon found at Deseret Industries

Kobe Bryant has two scoreless games

Olympics return in 2014

-- Nancy S. Bento

Utah joins civilized world

Wine recognized as food

-- Glen M. Burnham

All U.S. troops home

-- G. Edward Lloyd

New Deseret News editor, Joe Cannon, provides details on brother Chris, Abramoff ties

Supreme Court decides that only civil weddings are legal

Jeffs has revelation: A woman to replace him

-- Paul S. Carpenter

Finealee Edukashun Fundead Fairlee: Tax Exhempshun per child Eliminated

-- Jon Dewey

9 Comments:

At 7:10 AM, kingrook said...

The thing that most people fail to realize is that Kirby has Always been serious, but he cloaks it in humor & sarcasm to make the pill a little easier to swallow.

 
At 11:24 AM, Alienated Wannabe said...

Mormons do not exist

-- Matt Canham


Local ties to dolphin rescued in China

-- Holly Mullen


Rocky is a saint

-- Heather May


Paul Rolly appointed mayor of Cougar Town

-- Curtis Bramble


Six degrees of separation make all stories local

-- Holly Mullen


Mormons have never existed

-- Matt Canham


James Evans is the devil

-- Derek Jensen

 
At 7:38 AM, kabuki said...

Open to George Pyle:

Sadly, you're leaving the Tribune. Another of this city's brightest writers departs, in your case for greener turf, I hope. I've given the Trib some grief over the months of your Cave, but not to you. You've been patient with all of us and have even kept a sense of humor.

I just went to The Buffalo News' website and saw this forecast for this weekend. Not much accumulation of snow. For now! Don't forget your parka and moosehide mukluks!

-0-

Today A mix of light freezing rain...Snow and sleet into mid morning then rain or sleet likely this afternoon. Little or no snow and sleet accumulation. Highs in the mid 30s. Northeast winds 10 mph or less. Chance of precipitation 70 percent.
Tonight Sleet...Snow and freezing rain. Snow and sleet accumulation 1 to 3 inches. Lows around 30. Northeast winds 10 to 15 mph...Becoming east. Chance of precipitation near 100 percent.
Martin Luther Ki Freezing rain...Snow and sleet in the morning...Then snow and sleet in the afternoon. Additional snow and sleet accumulation 2 to 4 inches. Highs in the mid 30s. Northeast winds 10 to 15 mph. Chance of precipitation near 100 percent.

-0-

Good luck, George. You added class to an otherwise dull editorial section. I detected a love of Shakespeare, thoughtfulness, compassion and intelligence.

I wish you well.

Kabuki

 
At 10:04 AM, bud said...

Good bye George and all the best to you and your family. It was obvious you were not going to last long in this God forsaken place working for this God awful paper. Sorry about all the crap I and my aliases gave you regarding the cave.

 
At 8:18 PM, Alienated Wannabe said...

Dear George,

I am sad to hear that you are leaving the Tribune. Our loss is certainly Buffalo's gain. I hope you have a great experience in your home. God bless you!

Sincerely,
Alienated Wannabe

 
At 6:45 AM, Alienated Wannabe said...

Dear George,

What I meant to say was ". . . I hope you have a great experience in your NEW home. . . ." (Sorry about the typo!)

Sincerely,
Alienated Wannabe

 
At 7:13 AM, kingrook said...

Somebody needs to bury the moldering corpse & get on with it

 
At 11:11 AM, yukisama said...

Man, this site is stale. Just like the entire newspaper. I went through this morning's Tribune online and saw nothing that meant much to me or anyone else, as far as that goes.

A very lazy, unattractive newspaper. What Salt Lake City needs is a newspaper that has no sacred cows, like Singleton and his ilk, and the Deseret News, owned by the Mormon church and edited by an idiot who most recently headed the state's Republican party.

Yuk.

 
At 7:02 AM, Hazard said...

Talk about a hard working, dedicated, well paid ombudsman doing her job with great sweat, anxiety, depth, thoughtfulness, research, and truth-seeking!

The Tribune's "Reader Advocate" today, Saturday February 24, dedicated her entire column to a single letter-writer's opinions with but several innocuous observations that apparently are a defense of the writer's statements and observations.

As you can see, it must have taken the advocate about an hour, including time to sip coffee, to piece together her Saturday offering. Note her detailed responses to his precise comments. No specifics, no dates, times etc., of reporting on national issues.

The same is true of the editorial pages. All local. No guts to comment on the Bush administration's follies. That's outsourced to stringers and commentators published elsewhere to shield the paper's owner, Singleton, a buddy of the idiot president.

What a rag.

-0-

Reader Advocate: A dissatisfied reader wants more 'real news' in the paper

By Connie Coyne
Salt Lake Tribune Reader Advocate
Article Last Updated: 02/24/2007 01:09:20 AM MST

Once in a while, I get correspondence from a Salt Lake Tribune reader that goes beyond a simple complaint or comment requiring a short answer. This e-mail is one of those:
"I get it. I understand that the shooting spree at Trolley Square could be considered to be an 'epic' event in Utah. I understand that multiple unrelated victims were involved, and I understand that many in Utah have a neighborly human interest in keeping abreast of events. That much I get.
"I fail to understand how you believe that this local tragedy rises to such a level for the majority of Tribune readers that it is appropriate to consume 90 percent of the print space of the front page for five consecutive days.
"One likely justification, used in previous situations, is that the Tribune is responding to reader preference for more local content. Well, that is a false premise. The job of a credible newspaper is to provide appropriate news. Using the local content mantra to dumb down the newspaper is a disingenuous response.
"There are other issues of tremendous local interest, import and applicability that have been poorly covered by the Tribune. Here are a few suggestions for real investigative reporting with local interest:
* "Health care and the treatment of the uninsured are a national scandal and a disgrace. Fifteen percent of Utah's population is uninsured. The
Advertisement

difficulties faced by the uninsured ought to be covered in a way that informs those uninsured, as well as the general public, so they can respond appropriately to the action (or inaction) or our local and national leaders.
* "The war in Iraq. There have been the occasional wire service items, and there have been a few items with the deaths of Utah servicemen and women. Now that Congress is beginning to actually discuss issues that affect the actions of this country, this may be the time to draw the Utah public into the debate. I firmly believe Utahns are not stupid, nor are they hawks or rabid right-wingers. They are however over-worked, over-churched, over-stressed and often under-informed. If they had a newspaper diet high in facts, ideas, fiber and inspiration, they might be more willing to speak up on matters of importance.
* "The national economy. All reporting indicates the economy is like Valentine's Day - all chocolate and flowers. Well, that isn't true. There are some indicators that have been strong - the stock market, GDP, corporate profits, certainly CEO salaries and the rich have done well. Not everyone benefits from the rise of the Dow?
"How many in Utah are better off financially than 6 years ago. Probably not many.
"Finally, please reconsider what you put on the front page day after day. Please stop using local interest as a way to dodge printing real news. Use the same initiative, energy and enthusiasm you used for the Trolley Square tragedy to inform the public about things that are important."
Thank you for taking the time to thoroughly express your opinion. Obviously, you feel too much space was given to covering the Trolley Square tragedy, but you are in the minority on that issue if I take the expressions of other readers into consideration.
You feel we have done a poor job in covering health care, the war in Iraq and the national economy. I would argue against your opinion. Over the past 12 months, we have written numerous stories about the uninsured, the way the war in Iraq effects Utah families and the difference between the national economy and the Utah economy. We have written about the kinds of jobs lost and the kinds of jobs gained.
We do not use "local interest" as an excuse to "dodge printing real news." Local stories are real news and local news has more effect on the lives of Utahns than much of the news taking place in Washington or halfway around the world. Local schools educate local students; local companies employ local residents; local governments enact laws and ordinances as well as impose taxes that have a greater impact on local lives than national laws.
Many people today tell pollsters they get their national and world news from the Internet or TV, but they get their local news from their local newspapers, because they cannot get important local news anywhere else. That puts a big responsibility on the shoulders of journalists at The Tribune, but that responsibility is one we are proud to shoulder.
---
* THE READER ADVOCATE'S phone number is 801-257-8782. Write to the Reader Advocate, The Salt Lake Tribune, 90 S. 400 West, Suite 700, Salt Lake City, Utah 84101. reader.advocate@sltrib.com

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

Contributors:
Vern Anderson
Bio | E-mail
Pat Bagley
Bio | E-mail
Malin Foster
Bio | E-mail
Marilyn McKinnon
Bio | E-mail
Paul Wetzel
Bio | E-mail


Comment Disclaimer
The Salt Lake Tribune does not regulate or approve reader comments on blogs. Commenters should avoid offensive and defamatory language and keep comments on-topic. Users are encouraged to notify The Tribune of comments that do not adhere to these guidelines. E-mail us at webmaster@sltrib.com with the headline of the blog where the comment is posted. Persistent offenders may be blocked from posting.
Recent posts
Archives
   
Tribune Blogs
 
     

© Copyright 2007, The Salt Lake Tribune.
All material found on Utah Online is copyrighted The Salt Lake Tribune and associated news services. No material may be reproduced or reused without explicit permission from The Salt Lake Tribune.


Front Page | Contents | Search | World/Nation | Utah | Business | Sports | Editorials | Public Forum Letters | Commentary | Lifestyle | Movies | Travel | Health & Science | Faith | Archives | Weather | Obituaries

Columnists|Utah Politics | Filmfinder |
Contact Us | FAQ | Privacy Policy | Print Subscriptions | Reader Panel | Newspapers In Education

webmaster@sltrib.com

Moving Companies
Patio & Deck Covers
Mountain Bikes
Nanny Agency Great AuPair
Moissanite Engagement Ring
Gift Ideas
Moving
www.tinte-24.de
Si-Mexico Hotels Resorts
Bedroom Furniture
Rota Wheels
Compare Prices
Information Network
Gift Baskets & Gourmet Food
Natural Cures
Kars4Kids
Moving Companies