RSL Makes Right Call on Draft
Certainly, RSL would have preferred not to lose a young player as highly regarded as midfielder Nathan Sturgis, whom the Seattle Sounders selected today in the expansion draft.
But compared to the risk of losing goalkeeper Nick Rimando, it's nothing.
Remember, the team suddenly changed its mind after initially leaving Rimando unprotected for the draft, choosing at the last moment to leave Sturgis exposed, out of fear that the Sounders -- despite already having signed veteran goalkeeper Kasey Keller -- would select Rimando to use him for trade bait.
And even though the Sounders did not wind up selecting any of the starting goalkeepers that other teams had left exposed, the risk of losing the starting goalkeeper off the first playoff team in franchise history seems just to big to have taken.
Not only would it have looked foolish if it lost Rimando, but RSL also would have faced the prospect of either finding a new goalkeeper (after Rimando had become such an integral part of the team), trading something of value to get him back (something it already had to do after trading him away, to re-acquire him in the wake of Scott Garlick's unexpected retirement), or going into next season with current back-up Chris Seitz, who's highly regarded but still has played only three games in two seasons.
Uncertain options, all.
On top of that, Sturgis has scarcely played for RSL because of injuries since joining the team in a trade midway through the 2007 season. Eight games total, in fact -- and with different injuries that never seem to go away. With that kind of history (and a return to artificial turf in Seattle), it's difficult to bet your top goalkeeper that Sturgis is going to suddenly turn into the kind of regular starter who's going to make a real difference in this league.
Until he proves otherwise -- and good for Sturgis, if he does -- I'm going to say that RSL made the right move.
But compared to the risk of losing goalkeeper Nick Rimando, it's nothing.
Remember, the team suddenly changed its mind after initially leaving Rimando unprotected for the draft, choosing at the last moment to leave Sturgis exposed, out of fear that the Sounders -- despite already having signed veteran goalkeeper Kasey Keller -- would select Rimando to use him for trade bait.
And even though the Sounders did not wind up selecting any of the starting goalkeepers that other teams had left exposed, the risk of losing the starting goalkeeper off the first playoff team in franchise history seems just to big to have taken.
Not only would it have looked foolish if it lost Rimando, but RSL also would have faced the prospect of either finding a new goalkeeper (after Rimando had become such an integral part of the team), trading something of value to get him back (something it already had to do after trading him away, to re-acquire him in the wake of Scott Garlick's unexpected retirement), or going into next season with current back-up Chris Seitz, who's highly regarded but still has played only three games in two seasons.
Uncertain options, all.
On top of that, Sturgis has scarcely played for RSL because of injuries since joining the team in a trade midway through the 2007 season. Eight games total, in fact -- and with different injuries that never seem to go away. With that kind of history (and a return to artificial turf in Seattle), it's difficult to bet your top goalkeeper that Sturgis is going to suddenly turn into the kind of regular starter who's going to make a real difference in this league.
Until he proves otherwise -- and good for Sturgis, if he does -- I'm going to say that RSL made the right move.
